Week 29: Influence of ethics and Law on Professional Context

Week 29: Influence of ethics and Law on Professional Context

My Dilemma:
To protect the identity of those involved I have changed names and location, the dilemma is accurate.
I have been Principal of Nowhere school for five years. During my tenure, I employed a young beginning teacher, Ruth, who made a fine start to her teaching career with us and after graduating went on her big OE. I was happy to agree to be a referee for her. We stayed in touch on Facebook. It was great to see the fun things she did overseas - so far so good. However, on her return to NZ Ruth moved to another part of the country. She secured a teaching job and I was her referee. She had trouble settling as many do after their OE. Facebook was getting increasingly negative and there was the odd swipe at her new school. She then got into a relationship with a staff member, which was clearly volatile and that's when the trouble started. A former partner of the new boyfriend was clearly giving this young teacher a bit of a hard time. I knew this because the " no hole barred" story was playing out on Facebook, including the description of a punch-up between the Ruth and the ex-partner in a local shop. there were a lot of four-letter expletives describing the ex-girlfriend. Clearly, I was not the only one disturbed by the emotional and graphic outburst on social media, as at one stage Ruth let loose, telling all those who had told her to mind her language on Facebook to "Get F*#*ed!" She explained it was her personal account and she can say what she liked.  I could clearly see this teacher was under stress but using social media as her place to vent was so inappropriate.

The issues:
As a Facebook friend, I could offer support but she is on the other side of the country and the nature of her rants and the factors leading to the situation she was in were, very much, of her making.
As an educator, I knew her tirade was unprofessional and verging on unethical. I had reached out to help her when she was first having difficulties settling into her new school but getting involved in anything else I felt would have been inappropriate. I felt it was the job of her current employer to deal with any issues arising from her behaviour. At this stage, I was a concerned bystander.

The big issue came when she decided to leave her school and apply for a new job. I was contacted by a new school as I was a referee. The principal went through a series of fairly standard questions that asked me about her teaching, relationships with kids, skills in the core subjects, strengths and relationships with parents. From my experience of Ruth, they had all been very good. However, I knew better. Was it appropriate to mention what I had seen on Facebook? I was never asked about her personal life or her character but felt something needed to be said so waited until the end of the interview when they asked me if there was anything I would like to add. I told them that I would strongly advise them to Google Ruth's Facebook page as I had grave concerns about the ethics of what she had been posting. I felt sick having to say something and felt I had somewhat betrayed the teacher as I'm sure my comment would have wiped her out of contention for the job. Following this, I contacted the teacher and told her I couldn't be a referee for her anymore. I made an excuse that it had been too long a time since she had worked for me. At this stage, I had only been a Principal for about five or six years and had only had Facebook for two years so I think I was bit innocent in the downfalls of social media.  In recent years, as we have become more aware of cybersafety and developed robust policies within my own school, I have confidently spoken to staff on several occasions about things they have posted on Facebook that could be considered inappropriate when I have been made aware of them.

This issue clearly contravened the values that underpin the Education Councils Code (2017). In particular Pono - showing integrity by acting in ways that are fair, honest, ethical and just. Although the incidents described on her Facebook page happened in her private life, when she chose to publish it on Facebook, she places it in a public forum. This can be accessed by parents and students.

At Hampden Street, all staff signs the ICT RESPONSIBLE USE STAFF AGREEMENT. This document outline acceptable use of ICT and the internet and it reminds teaching staff; "Teachers should bear in mind that professional and ethical obligations are as applicable to activity online as they are to their daily interactions with students and the community in and out of school. The Teachers Council Code of Ethics provides a useful framework for decision making around what is and is not responsible ethical conduct."

If the same issue arose now, I feel I would deal directly with the person and confront them as a concerned member of the teaching profession even though she no longer worked for me. I would suggest they take down the offending posts. I believe it is vital that these issues are addressed to ensure the credibility of our profession.

References:
Our Code, Our Standard. (2017) Education Council New Zealand

ICT Responsibility Use Staff Agreement (2015) Hampden Street School, School Doc

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Week 28: Culturally Responsive Classrooms

Week 30: Professional Online Social Media

Week 31: My Interdisciplinary Connections