Week 28: Culturally Responsive Classrooms

Week 28: Culturally responsive Classrooms

As part of the work of our local Kahui Ako Ki Whakatu, we recently explored the idea of the culturally responsive classroom. With the assistance of our expert partner, Liz from Waikato University and our across school teachers, we carried out an observational audit of how culturally responsive the classrooms at our school are. The data and evidence gained from this exercise showed us that many teachers saw  cultural responsiveness as visual displays of Maori language or the occasional use of greetings or commands. Although these do have their place, in isolation they can be considered tokenism and superficial. For some teachers their class programmes lack a depth of understanding of cultural responsiveness. Gay (2001, p.106) defines it as " using the cultural characteristics, experiences and prospectives as conduits for teaching. The key message here is that cultural responsiveness is not just about using language or celebrating Matariki and Maori Language Week each year, it is our pedagogy - how we teach and, most importantly, how students learn. Teachers need to provide a student-led and driven programme, where students have a chance to learn in their context. As Russell Bishop puts it, "The environment created by the teachers is such that Maori students feel they can be part of the learning conversation." A popular definition of cultural responsiveness refers to peoples ability to acknowledge and respect the culture of our students. I believe it is about the depth at which we acknowledge and respect student's cultures. In too may classrooms this happens at a superficial level.

The Education Council's Cultural Competencies document, Tataiako (2011) was developed to help  teachers in engaging and building relationships with Maori learners and their whanau. It identifies 5 key competencies: Wänanga, Manaakitanga, Tangata Whenuatanga, Whanaungatanga, and Ako. A class programme where the teacher can understand and articulate these competencies in their practice, along with an emphasis on the Key competencies is, I believe, a true 21st learning environment. The Tataiako competences sit well with what the framework of a student-led pedagogy should look like. One where contexts for learning are relevant and authentic to students, whanau is engaged and actively involved and outcomes are genuine. This approach to learning benefits all learners.
from TÄTAIAKO: CULTURAL COMPETENCIES FOR TEACHERS OF MÄORI LEARNERS (2011)

Our Context: 
Since 2013 our school pedagogy has gone through a huge transformation into a student-led focus across the school. This started with our year 5/6 area and has moved down through the school over the years. We are still on the journey, but are proud of the progress so far. This short film highlights some of our successes: Student-led learning at HSS.
This style of "open ended" learning has led to better engagement in learning from our Maori students. Their achievement in core subjects has improved, which was recognised by ERO in our 2017 report. They also recognised that we "use innovative approaches to keep children whose learning is at-risk connected to the school and their learning." Our innovative programmes such as Genius Hour, STEM day and Discovery Time provide opportunities for tamariki to explore their learning in their own context and drive it themselves. I believe the key to this success is ownership and buy-in from key stakeholders; staff, whanau and most importantly the students. In fact, students were the easiest group to get buy-in from as this change in approach directly benefited them and their learning. It better connected with their needs.

We have had a lot of success engaging with our students in our student-led learning environment and along with this whanau engagement has improved. However, I do believe this is an area we need to further strengthen. We need robust and responsive relationships with our Maori parents and wider whanau, Tangata Whenuatanga. As part of our pedagogical development we have explored and promoted the idea of personalised learning, we must apply the same principle to our engagement with whanau. We must recognise the various backgrounds and family situations our tamariki come from and not apply a "one hat fits all" approach to communication with whanau. Teachers need to engage with the whanau so they know where the family is from, their iwi, and whakapapa. We also need to establish school wide systems of recording down this information, maybe on the our SMS, so it informs future teachers.

References:
Gay, G. (2002) Preparing for Culturally Responsive Teaching. Journal of Teacher Education, 53(2), 106-116

Bishop, R. Source: EdTalks (2012, September 23) Aculturally responsive pedagogy of relations (Video file). Retrived from https://vimeo/49992994

Student-led Learning at Hampden Street School (2015) video Clip retrieved from http://elearning.tki.org.nz/Connected-learning-Advisory. Ministry of Education. Wellington. 

Ministry of Education (2011). Tataiako: Cultural Competencies for Teachers of Māori Learners. Ministry of Education. Wellington.  

Comments

  1. Kia ora, it's interesting just how far we have come from 'days of the week' on the whiteboard and learning a few Maori phrases (not that I'm knocking teachers who try, after all we know what we know until we know more!). I think when Ka Hikitia and Tataiako were first introduced to schools, they were kind of 'flicked onto the table' and teachers were left wondering what to do with it and what it might actually look like in their classrooms. I like the analogy of the Cultural iceberg (http://www.united-church.ca/sites/default/files/resources/cultural-iceberg.pdf) where, as you mention, it is the depth of understanding that counts. I think it's a good model for initiating discussion of what CRP could look like both 'at our school' and 'in my classroom'.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi - interesting to read that you too find that interface between teacher and whanau needs to be strengthened. I find that at my school also, it is a low SES area, and I have to say it is not only Maori whanau with whom I would like to be able to establish much stronger ties!

    ReplyDelete
  3. HI,

    I enjoyed the video and liked the look of the school. You seem to have open plan classrooms and lots of computers, I am very envious. What struck me was that you have not gone down the route of 'Te Reo' as your strategy for engaging Maori learners. Instead you have looked at your structure and pedagogy and I feel this is a more radical but successful way of helping all students to learn.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree with Paula above Don. It is great to be exploring the issue of engaging our Maori learners through a change in structure and pedagogy. This has been my approach this year also which has been more successful for all and engagement levels have definitely improved. I enjoyed reading your post.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Kia ora tatou! I really enjoyed reading your blog and it is inspirational to view how you are approaching student agency with regard to learning. Having just relocated to Nelson from the Bay of Plenty, I have found that culturally responsive and relational pedagogy is not always top of the agenda in an area where only 10% of students affiliate as Maori. However, you seem to have embraced many of the important aspects that contribute towards Maori ako achieving as Maori. As the Te Kotahitanga document revealed, learning for Maori students is accelerated when 'power is shared... culture counts... and learning is interactive and dialogic' (Bishop & Berryman, 2010). This ideal is continued in Tataiako, so well done on embracing this!

    Reference: R. Bishop & M. Berryman (2010) Te Kotahitanga: Culturally responsive professional development for teachers.. Routledge Taylor & Francis Group.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Don,

    Progress is a positive motion forward. The movement from exclusive pedagogical practice to a more inclusive environment demonstrates an "awakening" (Bishop 2012) and promotion of acceptance and cultural openness that benefits all participants, directly and indirectly.

    Reaching out to whanau engages the home and school as healthy partners in the students educational journey. The advantages of this approach are sometimes intangible or not easily measured. The sense of connection (Taha wairua) joins the parties together as active participants in their childs development as Durie (1999) alludes to below.

    Taha wairua incorporates 'the experience of mutually rewarding encounters between people, a sense of communion with the environment, access to heritage and cultural integrity'.

    Culturally responsive practice and connection with the community also was shown by Cowie et al (2012) to have tangible benefits. Primary schools continue to be ahead of high schools in this regard. AS Hilary said, the path to the top of the mountain begins with one small step.

    Enjoy your progress.


    Bishop, R (2012). https://app.themindlab.com/media/12844/view

    Cowie et al, (2012). Culturally responsive pedagogy and assessment in primary science classrooms: Whakamana tamariki. Teaching and Learning Research Initiative. www.tlri.org.nz

    Durie, Mason (1999), 'Te Pae Mahutonga: a model for Mäori health promotion', Health. Promotion Forum of New Zealand Newsletter 49, 2-5 December 1999.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Well done Don, almost there. I believe we are going to get the best from our cultural students by having the strongest and most positive relationship we can with them. This obviously means we have to go extra effort to get to know our students and thus build trust in them. They can then see us as a trusted adult, which they may not get from home. Saying this it is really hard to get quality bonding time during our mental school days. Maybe labour might have the solution!!!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi Don, I really enjoyed reading your blog post, and the associated comments. I can relate to the journey your school has been on, as we are on the same journey - from visible and tangible cultural practises (the arts, language etc) to more of an understanding of the pedagogy shift that is needed to ensure all students' needs are met. It is awesome to see so many extra resources or research papers that people have shared also.
    We continue to attempt to connect in new and varied ways with our whānau - absolutely one size does not fit all, and having a range of approaches seems to create the best connections.
    As a classroom teacher, I also looked into finding out more about my students hapu and iwi, but although I had some students who knew where they were from, I had many did not. I found this a challenge - as often the whānau also had a limited understanding. One of my puzzles is, how do we help students and their whānau get a sense of belonging to our school, along with their Marae, hapu and iwi, if they have never had this before?

    ReplyDelete
  9. Kia ora anō e hoa,

    He rangitaki ruku hōhonu, whai māramatanga hoki.
    An in depth and insightful blog post.

    Interesting also to see that your reflection on creating culturally responsive classrooms has aroused a flurry of comments and diverse range of responses.

    I am pleased to note that you believe depth to be key in acknowledging and respecting students' cultures and that you are awakened to the superficial homage that takes place all too often in classrooms and schools.

    I feel for teachers who despite a strong desire to create a culturally responsive classroom culture through indigenous practice find themselves feeling inadequately proficient to do so. This in essence is an area in which I, and other Resource Teachers of Māori, can provide support.

    The good news is, by teachers sharing with students that Te Reo me ōna Tikanga is something which they themselves are still learning and deeply desire to do so, it models to the students that teachers are also learners, that opportunities to learn about our indigenous culture through the education system have been rare and that every effort we make now is therefore precious.

    Like Paula and Rachel who commented above, I too think it is great that you have been exploring the issue of engaging Maori learners through a change in structure and pedagogy. Rather than as an alternative pathway however, to teaching and learning Te Reo at school, I personally believe (and professional promote) the learning of Te Reo together with students, and where students have knowledge the teacher doesn't, switching the teacher/learner roles. In my view, without Te Reo me ōna Tikanga having value and presence in a school, other culturally responsive initiatives cannot avoid becoming 'token' over time.

    And now Don, my old T-Col colleague, I offer a cultural challenge for you in recognition of your public profile as an innovative school principal. With this year's Mind Lab study workload out of the way how about taking on Te Reo as part of your professional development curriculum. I would be happy to mentor you along the way!

    Toi tū te kupu, toi tū te mana, toi tū te whenua.

    Arohanui,
    Tania :-)

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Week 30: Professional Online Social Media

Week 31: My Interdisciplinary Connections